Maybelline Sky High Review: Can a $11 Mascara Rival High-End Brands?
People with short or straight lashes looking for maximum extension and a clump-free, everyday finish.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara — lengthening, washable black
$10.82
Affiliate disclosure: we earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
The Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara is designed for those who prioritize extreme length and lash definition over thick, heavy volume. It features a unique, flexible 'Flex Tower' brush that bends to coat every single lash from root to tip, making it a go-to for users with shorter lashes who want a wide-eyed look without the clumps typical of fiber-heavy formulas.
At a price point of $10.82, this washable formula is aimed at the daily wearer who needs a reliable, flake-free finish that can be removed easily at the end of the day. If you prefer a lightweight feel that doesn't weigh down your natural curl, this is one of the most effective drugstore options available.
What's good
- Delivers noticeable vertical length without using heavy fibers
- The flexible wand reaches tiny inner-corner lashes easily
- Washable formula removes quickly with warm water and basic cleanser
- Minimal flaking or smudging throughout an 8-hour wear period
- Lightweight texture that keeps lashes feeling soft, not crunchy
What's not
- The 'Flex Tower' wand can be difficult to control if you prefer a rigid brush
- Requires multiple coats to achieve any significant volume or thickness
How to choose in this category
When shopping for a drugstore mascara, the first step is identifying your lash type and your primary goal. Mascaras generally fall into three categories: lengthening, volumizing, or curling. Formulas like Sky High use a thinner, more fluid consistency to stretch the pigment past the natural tip of the lash. If you have thick lashes but they are short, a lengthening formula is your best bet. However, if your lashes are sparse, you might find a lengthening mascara leaves them looking a bit 'spidery,' and you should look for formulas labeled specifically for volume or density. The applicator material also changes the outcome significantly. Plastic or elastomer brushes, like the one found here, are superior for separation and preventing clumps because the bristles are usually spaced precisely to comb through the hair. Traditional fiber brushes are better for depositing large amounts of product quickly to build bulk. Another factor to consider is the weight of the formula; heavy, wax-based mascaras can often cause lashes to lose their curl over the course of the day. Lightweight, water-based formulas are less likely to pull lashes downward but may not provide that dramatic 'theatrical' look. Finally, consider your removal routine. If you have sensitive eyes or wear contacts, a washable formula is often preferable because it requires less rubbing and tugging at the delicate eye area compared to long-wear waterproof options which require oil-based removers.
The verdict
The Sky High Mascara is a standout for separation and incredible length that holds up through a full workday. While it won't give you the 'false lash' thickness of a volumizing formula, its ability to fan out lashes is unmatched at this price. The only real caveat is the flexible wand, which can feel a bit flimsy if you are used to stiff, traditional applicators.
See it nowFrequently asked
Is Maybelline Sky High Mascara waterproof or washable?
This specific version is the washable formula, meaning it is designed for easy removal. There is a separate waterproof version available if you need moisture resistance.
Does Sky High Mascara smudge on oily eyelids?
While it is flake-resistant, some users with very oily lids may experience slight transfer. Using a setting powder under the eyes can help mitigate this.
Is it easy to remove Sky High mascara?
Yes, the washable formula is designed to dissolve with standard makeup remover or even just warm water and soap, preventing lash breakage during cleansing.
Can you layer Sky High for more volume?
You can layer it, but it is best to do so while the first coat is still slightly damp. Once it dries, adding more layers can lead to slight clumping.